← All insights
Science Personality and relationships

Is Birth Order Theory Real? What Family Studies Show

The CQ Team · 9 min read ·

Mostly not. Studies of 20,186 people found no birth order effect on four Big Five traits, only a 1.5-point IQ edge per position for older siblings.

Birth order theory has little support in modern data. The largest studies, which compare tens of thousands of people across families and siblings inside the same family, find no effect of birth order on extraversion, emotional stability, agreeableness or conscientiousness. Two small effects hold up: IQ drops about 1.5 points with each step down the birth order, and firstborns rate themselves slightly higher on intellect. A 2025 study of more than 700,000 test-takers found middle children a little more honest and agreeable, but most of that gap tracks how many siblings people had, and not where they fell in line.

Where did birth order theory come from?

The idea is older than psychology as a lab science. In 1874 Francis Galton noticed that firstborns were over-represented among English scientists, and about half a century later the psychiatrist Alfred Adler, the second of six children, turned birth order into a theory of personality, as Rohrer, Egloff and Schmukle (2015) recount.

Where do you land? The free MBTI test is 12 questions, about 3 minutes, no sign-up.

Start the test →

Adler set the idea out in Understanding Human Nature (1927), in a chapter called "The Family Constellation". He described the oldest child as a guardian of law and order with a high regard for power, the youngest as a child given especially solicitous treatment, and the only child as someone who may see the world as hostile. These were impressions from his clinical work. The chapter reports no counts, no comparison groups and no measurements.

Most of what birth order articles say today, from the responsible firstborn to the forgotten middle child, is a restatement of Adler's chapter or of later popular books built on it.

What do the largest studies find?

The strongest test so far is Rohrer, Egloff and Schmukle (2015), published in PNAS. They pooled three national panels: 5,240 people in the US, 4,489 in Great Britain and 10,457 in Germany, 20,186 in all. They ran the analysis two ways. Between families, they compared firstborns with later-borns from different homes, holding family size constant. Within families, they compared siblings with each other.

TraitEffect of birth order
ExtraversionNone
Emotional stabilityNone
AgreeablenessNone
ConscientiousnessNone
ImaginationNone
Self-rated intellectAbout 0.10 standard deviations lower per later position
Measured IQAbout 1.5 points lower per later position

The sample was large enough to detect a gap as small as 5% of a standard deviation between first- and later-borns, with 95% power. The null results held when the authors compared only firstborns with lastborns, when they looked only at same-sex pairs, and when they limited age gaps to 1.5 to 5 years. Their conclusion was that birth order has no meaningful, lasting effect on the broad Big Five traits outside the intellectual domain.

Rodica Damian and Brent Roberts had reached the same place with US high school students in Project Talent. Writing about both studies in PNAS (2015), they reported that the average birth order effect in their sample equalled a correlation of 0.02, and that even the largest effects were too small for parents, relatives, siblings or friends to notice. Their verdict: birth order is not an important factor in personality development.

Why do families see differences the studies miss?

Inside one family, birth order and age move together. The firstborn is always older, so at any family dinner the oldest child looks more mature, more responsible and more in charge. Damian and Roberts point to this confound in the same commentary: people watch older children act differently and credit their position in the family.

Earlier studies that seemed to confirm birth order effects often had a second problem. Rohrer and colleagues note that the studies supporting the main modern version of the theory used a within-family design in which one sibling rated everyone, so the rater's own stereotypes about older and younger siblings could shape the scores. The 2015 study used age-adjusted scores and asked each person to describe themselves.

A quick check you can run on your own family: are you comparing your siblings as they are now, or as each of them was at the same age?

Do firstborns have a higher IQ?

Yes, by a small margin. In Rohrer et al. (2015), IQ fell by about 1.5 points, or 10% of a standard deviation, with each step down the birth order, in both the between-family and the within-family analyses.

The authors put that size in plain terms. In two-child families, a randomly picked firstborn had a 52% chance of a higher IQ than a randomly picked secondborn. Within the same family, the older sibling had the higher IQ in 6 of 10 pairs, which means the younger sibling scored higher in the other 4.

The cause looks social more than biological. A study of about 250,000 Norwegian military conscripts by Kristensen and Bjerkedal (2007) found that IQ followed the rank a child was raised in, and not biological birth order.

Self-rated intellect showed the same small slope, and it stayed after the authors controlled for measured IQ. Firstborns see themselves as a little more intellectual than their IQ alone would predict.

Are later-borns more rebellious?

This claim comes from Frank Sulloway's 1996 book Born to Rebel, which argued that firstborns are more conservative, more supportive of authority and more tough-minded than later-borns, the rebels of the title. Sulloway reported that birth order predicted social attitudes better than gender, class or race.

Tests on modern samples have not backed it. Freese, Powell and Steelman (1999) checked 24 measures of social attitudes in the US General Social Survey, then all 202 relevant items. They found no support, either in significant effects or in the direction of the non-significant ones. Gender, race, social class and family size all predicted attitudes more strongly than birth order. Townsend (2000) re-analysed six of Sulloway's own samples and his meta-analysis, and concluded that the birth order claims should be rejected.

A follow-up on narrower traits, Rohrer, Egloff and Schmukle (2017) in Psychological Science, tested risk-taking, patience, impulsivity, trust, life satisfaction, sense of control and political orientation in German panel data with up to 10,628 people. None of the median differences between first- and later-borns reached 0.06 standard deviations. Intellect was the only trait where the earlier effect came back.

Is there any evidence for middle child syndrome?

Middle child syndrome is not a diagnosis. Cleveland Clinic states that birth order "syndromes" have no official medical or psychological diagnosis, and no peer-reviewed study we found defines it as a measurable condition.

The closest testable idea is that middle children feel less close to their families. A 1998 study by Salmon and Daly found middleborns less likely to name their mother as the person they felt closest to. When Simanko, Rimmer and Pollet (2020) tested this in two samples of Dutch and German adults, matching 59 middleborns with 59 others and then 74 middleborns with 109 others on sex, age, education, nationality and family size, they found no difference in emotional closeness to parents, siblings or friends. The statistics favoured no difference over a small one. They also note that an earlier attempt by Hardman and colleagues (2007) failed to replicate the 1998 result.

What did the 2025 study of 700,000 people find?

One large study does report birth order differences, and it is the strongest case for the theory. Ashton and Lee (2025), the psychologists behind the HEXACO model, analysed 710,797 adults who completed the 100-item HEXACO inventory online, and a second sample of 74,920 who also reported how many siblings they had.

ComparisonHonesty-HumilityAgreeableness
Middle children vs only childrend = 0.21 to 0.24d = 0.24 to 0.27
Families of six or more children vs only childrend = 0.30d = 0.36
Oldest vs middle and youngest, same family sizeup to d = 0.10 lowerup to d = 0.10 lower

A d of 0.10 is a tenth of a standard deviation. Middle children scored highest on honesty and agreeableness, then youngest, oldest and only children. Most of that ranking reflects family size: middle children come from larger families by definition, and people from larger families scored higher. Within the same family size, the gaps shrank to about 0.10 or less. Within family size, oldest children also scored about 0.10 higher on openness.

Ashton and Lee argue that earlier studies missed these effects because their scales were short. The US panel in the 2015 study measured each Big Five trait with two items. That is a fair point about measurement. The new data have limits of their own: the participants chose to take the test on the HEXACO website, most were from English-speaking countries, and the authors disclose that they receive royalties for non-academic use of the HEXACO inventory.

So does birth order shape who you are?

Read together, the studies agree on more than the headlines suggest. If birth order shapes broad traits at all, the effect is about a tenth of a standard deviation, the size Damian and Roberts judge too small for family or friends to notice. If you want to see where you sit on honesty-humility or agreeableness, the HEXACO test and the Big Five test on Cerebral Quotient are short tests in the style of those frameworks, not the official inventories.

How we checked: we read the full text of Rohrer, Egloff and Schmukle (2015 and 2017), Damian and Roberts's 2015 PNAS commentary, Ashton and Lee (2025), Simanko, Rimmer and Pollet (2020) and the relevant chapter of Adler (1927), and the abstracts of Kristensen and Bjerkedal (2007), Freese, Powell and Steelman (1999), Townsend (2000), Falbo and Polit (1986) and Damian and Spengler (2020).

Sources

For related reading, see what the research says about agreeableness scores, how the HEXACO test differs from the Big Five, whether your personality type can change, and every post on personality and relationships.

Frequently asked questions

Is birth order theory debunked?

For broad personality traits, mostly yes. Studies of 20,186 people in three countries and of US high school students in Project Talent found no meaningful birth order effect on extraversion, emotional stability, agreeableness or conscientiousness. The effect on IQ, about 1.5 points per position, is real and small. A 2025 study of 710,797 people found small differences in honesty and agreeableness, most of them explained by family size.

Is oldest child syndrome real?

It is not a diagnosis. Adler held that firstborns are prone to neuroticism after a younger sibling dethrones them, but the 2015 PNAS study found no birth order effect on emotional stability or conscientiousness. The one consistent firstborn difference is a slightly higher IQ and self-rated intellect.

Is only child syndrome real?

The evidence does not support the stereotype of the lonely or spoiled only child. A review of 117 studies by Falbo and Polit (1986) found only children matched firstborns and people from two-child families on achievement and intelligence, and did better than people from families of three or more children on adjustment and character. Ashton and Lee (2025) found only children scored slightly lower on honesty-humility and agreeableness, a gap of about a fifth to a quarter of a standard deviation compared with middle children.

Does birth order affect career choice?

Only slightly. Damian and Spengler (2020) followed 3,763 Americans from Project Talent for 50 years. Birth order effects on career type, education, occupational prestige and income ranged from 0.02 to 0.12 on a correlation scale, with firstborns slightly ahead on education and prestige. Intelligence and education carried those effects, and personality did not.

Curious where you sit? The MBTI test is free, takes about 3 minutes, and needs no sign-up.

Take the MBTI test →

Keep reading

All Personality and relationships articles →
Science

Are Love Languages Real? What the Research Says

8 min read →
Psychology 101

Attachment Styles Explained: The 4 Styles in Relationships

8 min read →
Psychology 101

MBTI Compatibility Chart: Every Type Pair, and What Research Says

6 min read →